There's no shortage of pizza places serving skiers on Route 4 between Woodstock and Rutland. But only one eating establishment on the road to Killington was designated by Food & Wine magazine as one of the top 25 restaurants in the country. Well-heeled diners motor up the mountain to get a taste of Hemingway's, where Chef Ted Fondulas has manned the kitchen for 25 years; his wife, Linda, manages the front of the house and fine-tunes its rustic-elegant charm. You can dine in a small room with a fireplace, in the wine cellar or in a grand dining area.
Edible options abound as well. The tasting menu provides smaller portions of dishes from the à la carte side, with wine pairings available.
One can't-miss appetizer is the triumphant tourchon of duck liver, which arrives with buttery brioche and quince. The delicate bitterness of the quince is a perfect foil for the gamy, fatty liver. The super-creamy garlic soup, which was once featured in Bon Appétit, is just as rich.
The entrée selection includes a sublime Vermont pheasant with local mushrooms and delicate handmade gnocchi. Too adventurous? Try the tenderloin of beef with fingerling potatoes and baby vegetables.
The creative cheese course features three miniature grilled Vermont-cheese sandwiches, each with a topping that complements the flavors. Other after-dinner options include a decadent "chocolate present" with winter cherries and warm hazelnut cookies, which goes perfectly with a glass of port.
Libation lovers will find plenty of possibilities, too. The wine list is deep and far-ranging, with over 175 options. Want a $700 bottle of Chateau d'Yquem? No problem! Even teetotalers get spoiled — the restaurant thoughtfully offers an alcohol-free beverage pairing for non-drinkers.